Cap and Trade is a cap on our economic growth

There are many reasons to dislike the Cap and Trade bill. Today I write about the most damaging part of this bill which I do not see mentioned anywhere.

Cap and Trade will cap our country’s economic growth. Ideally we want the US economy to grow. You can not have economic growth without increasing energy consumption. Increased energy consumption results in increased carbon emissions. Cap and Trade places a cap on the amount of carbon that can be emitted by all industry in our country by limiting the amount of carbon credits that are made available.

growth-capWe can now look at this in terms of supply and demand. The government will reduce the supply of carbon credits over time. If the economy is growing, the demand for carbon credits will be increasing. When you reduce supply and increase demand you ALWAYS increase price. So the price of carbon credits will increase. Increasing carbon credit prices will retard the growth of the US economy. It not only retards growth but it caps it.

There is a point where it will not make sense to conduct business because the cost of production is too high. If this market operates efficiently, and I think it will, companies will simply determine their breaking point and operate to that point. Weaker companies will go out of business and lack of supply will increase the cost for good and services. Initially it makes sense that market with low profit margins will re-situate themselves first but no industry will be immune. Prices will rise to maintain margins but at some point people will not be able to buy.

So what happens when this tax squelches production? The product or service will be produced elsewhere. So where will they be produced? As soon as the cost of delivery, tariffs, and production drops below the cost of the carbon tax, production WILL go elsewhere. We have actually seen this happen in many products and service already due to increased labor costs in this country and the availability of cheap labor in other countries. Have you called tech support recently? Do we really need to drive production to other countries?

So what happens when production is pushed to other countries that do not participate in carbon emission taxation and countries without clean air standards? How does that effect the carbon footprint of that good or service? I have not formally calculated the carbon footprint of anything but I am guessing that when you add up the emission of carbon in the transportation of goods and the lack of regulation in countries where the goods are produces I am going to guess that the carbon footprint will increase.

This bill does NOTHING to decrease carbon emissions and the administrator of the EPA freely admits this.

So what DOES this bill do?

  1. Caps growth on our economy
  2. Increases worldwide carbon emissions
  3. Creates unemployment in the private sector
  4. Creates a LOT of government jobs
  5. Creates a trading market for carbon credits
    1. Creates unregulated derivative markets for carbon credits
    2. Transfers massive amounts of wealth to companies that trade carbon credits. (Al Gore is a significant investor in such a company)
  6. Increases the amount that everyone pays for energy such as electricity, home oil, gasoline, etc…
  7. Increased the price of EVERYTHING that we buy.
  8. Carves out allowances for interest groups that have “paid their due”

In summary it is my opinion that this energy bill (cap and trade) will be the single most damaging piece of legislation that our country could pass. This legislation is a mechanism designed to tax every citizen and visitor to this country. This legislation transfers wealth to the players in the carbon trading markets. This legislation has nothing at all to do about climate change or the health or welfare of any United States citizen.

Posted in

Erik Blazynski


  1. Dimsdale on July 14, 2009 at 5:54 pm

    It's about redistribution of wealth and, naturally, the government skims off the top.

    It is just another method of control by the government over private industries. Invent a crisis (AGW), create a monster (CO2), find a scapegoat (capitalism and big business), regulate the industry into bankruptcy. We will see it in energy, health care, transportation, banking, insurance, you name it. History once again repeating itself.

    And all under the direction of a political cipher and economic amateur.


  2. sammy22 on July 15, 2009 at 2:22 am

    Coal in the US is mostly used to produce electricity. Replace coal produced electricity w/ nuclear and you have no CO2 emissions. France produces ALL its electricity w/ nuclear and hydro, they closed their last coal mine years ago. There are options….. if we have the will….

The website's content and articles were migrated to a new framework in October 2023. You may see [shortcodes in brackets] that do not make any sense. Please ignore that stuff. We may fix it at some point, but we do not have the time now.

You'll also note comments migrated over may have misplaced question marks and missing spaces. All comments were migrated, but trackbacks may not show.

The site is not broken.